Apparently you can get an entirely different route that's 65 miles shorter by adding addresses instead of just useng city names. Wtf?
The city-names-only route involved here > IN-2 > I-65 > Indianapolis > I-70 > destination. (325mi)
The with-addresses is here > US-30 > Ft. Wayne > OH-309 > OH-117 > US-33 > destination... (260mi)
On a side note, I should /so/ butcher that "who is driving?/Bear is driving/etc..." userpic for my own uses someday... :D